In a new paper released Wednesday, entitled “How the Great Recession Was Brought to an End,” prominent economists Alan Blinder and Mark Zandi say the stimulus, stress tests, emergency Federal Reserve maneuvers and Troubled Asset Relief Program saved the economy from collapse.
Without those extraordinary measures, they say, the United States’ GDP would be 6.5 percent lower, the unemployment rate would be 3 percentage points higher, there would be 8.5 million fewer jobs and the economy would be experiencing deflation. Blinder is a professor at Princeton and a former Fed official. Zandi is the chief economist at Moody’s Analytics and a former adviser to U.S. Sen. John McCain’s presidential campaign.
The economists also note that the stimulus — the $787 billion American Reinvestment and Recovery Act — had less impact and proved less important than the government’s monetary policy and financial-market stabilization measures, like the Fed buy-up of mortgage-backed securities.
Zandi and Blinder write:
It is understandable that the still-fragile economy and the massive budget deficits have fueled criticism of the government’s response. No one can know for sure what the world would look like today if policymakers had not acted as they did — our estimates are just that, estimates. It is also not difficult to find fault with isolated aspects of the policy response. [...]
While all of these questions deserve careful consideration, it is clear that laissez faire was not an option; policymakers had to act. Not responding would have left both the economy and the government’s fiscal situation in far graver condition. We conclude that [Federal Reserve Chairman] Ben Bernanke was probably right when he said that “We came very close in October [2008] to Depression 2.0.”






View Comments
Pingback posted July 28, 2010 @ 2:52 pm
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by COindependent, Áine MacDermot. Áine MacDermot said: RT @COindependent: Top analysts find government action saved U.S. economy http://bit.ly/9ClgOq [...]
Pingback posted July 28, 2010 @ 11:07 pm
[...] Top analysts find government action saved U.S. economy « Colorado … [...]
Comment posted July 29, 2010 @ 6:56 am
“Saved the economy” is just another way of saying it kept the stock market from collapsing. There are millions of workers out of work that are being told that it is their own fault for being lazy that would argue we are in depression 2.0 right now.
The propped up stock market will not last long.
Like the “Right” reminds us lefties all the time; “If you give them government money to live on, they won't work for it.”
While the working class were thrown out of their overpriced homes, big banks and wall street were standing at the welfare office (Federal Reserve) with their hands out.
Steal $100 and you are a criminal. Steal $100 million and you are a business person.
You gotta love capitalism
Pingback posted July 29, 2010 @ 8:46 am
[...] Top analysts find government action saved U.S. economy Colorado …Global Voices in English Saudi Arabia: Muttawa in ActionAugust action materials now available RESULTS UK News and Views [...]
Comment posted July 29, 2010 @ 5:46 pm
You are right concerning the repubs outrageous attempt to smear unemployed workers and deny them extended benefits. This cruel and foolish move by the GOP just may come back to haunt them and they will deserve every drop of political blood they pay for their miserly attempts to play politics at the expense of the unemployed.
Regarding the stock market I don't entirely agree that it is “propped up” and is going to fail anytime soon. There is billions in cash waiting on the sidelines to be invested as the economy slogs forward and it will find it's way back into stocks and bonds.
So many opinions in the offing regarding stocks makes for a confusing brew at times. The market has a life of its own and if anything does it's own “propping up” based upon market values and corporate profits. Let the buyer beware as they say. Thats capitalism.
True the Federal Reserve has played a huge role in this recovery by offering low rate loans through the discount window and the big banks have profited as a result. But this is the Feds way of pumping cash the lifeblood of our economy back into the system and it is working.
I do love capitalism with a grain of government regulation thrown in for good measure.
Comment posted July 30, 2010 @ 8:40 am
ナイキ エアマックスを買うならAirMax123。ナイキエアマックス(NIKE AIR MAX)激安通販ショップ、air max激安を格安価格で販売します!激安 ナイキ エアマックスはナイキを代表するaimax スニーカーランニングシューズであります。2003年に発売されましたスニーカー エアマックス(AIR MAX 2003)。エアマックスは柔軟性やクッション性のある機能性は もちろんのこと、フルレングスエアマックス 通販搭載の厚めのゴムソー ルなので、airmax 通販さりげなく脚長 効果もありエアマックス 激安、足を自然にきれいに見せてくれますエアマックス メンズ。アッパーには上 質なレザーを採用しましたベーシックなフォルムなのでどんなスタ イルにもはまるオススメのエアマックス レディースモデルです。
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.