State Sen. John Morse has one thing to say about some people who are continuing to viciously attack Rep. Michael Merrifield, including actually making fun of the fact that he has cancer.
“He took responsibility for what he wrote, and this is how despicable it is: This is a 60-year old man who is fighting for his physical life. He’s battling cancer, very courageously, and if you want to continue to kick him while he’s down, well, you know I just don’t spent my time poking people who are fighting cancer in the eye, and I don’t know of any decent people who do either.”
Merrifield’s e-mail message, sent last December, was widely reported – and largely misinterpreted – after a Republican operative recently obtained it via an open records request and posted it on his website. In the message, written to Sen. Sue Windels, Merrifield noted that there must be a “special place in hell for these Privatizers, Charerizers (sic) and Voucherziers.” Specifically, in his e-mail Merrifield was referring to recalled D-11 board members Eric Christen and Sandy Shakes – and not everyone who happens to support charters,
Since the e-mail was publicized, Merrifield has apologized. He has stepped down, for the remainder of the legislative session, as chairman of the House Education Committee. But a vocal minority are still calling for his head. Some anonymous right wing blog sites have actually resorted to calling Merrifield names – including “washed up choir teacher” – and talking about the “irony” that he has cancer of the throat. Merrifield is currently undergoing chemotherapy treatments.
“The Republicans are trying to stir this pot for all its worth and then some,” Morse said. “Some of the groups he’s been opposed to have seen it as an opening to make hay, but they’ve got to be careful because they’ve overreached.”
Morse is the only other Democrat in the legislature from El Paso County – and has received his own share of ferocious attacks leading up to his trouncing of former Sen. Ed Jones last November, describes the assault as just one more example of many he’s witnessed this year involving the minority party.
But beyond all the rhetoric, Merrifield’s enemies are overlooking one simple, but important fact, Morse said: “He’s doing a really good job of representing his district.”
“If that offends some people then oh, well. He certainly had no intention of [his e-mail] becoming public, and while he used an unfortunate phrase, he believes that charter schools undo public education and strip resources. From what little I’ve heard he’s in tune with the majority of his constituents.”
Merrifield, a retired teacher, is in his fourth term representing a district encompassing much of central and western Colorado Springs, and the city of Manitou Springs. An ardent and vocal advocate of public schools, he’s faced tough Republican challenges, including from candidates with backing from wealthy pro-voucher advocates.
In November he handily swatted away his latest Republican challenger Kyle Fisk, receiving nearly 61 percent of the vote. Fisk, an associate pastor of a New Life Church affiliate, had received the support of developer Steve Schuck, a longtime leader in the battle to install school vouchers statewide. He also was promoted by his former boss, then-Pastor Ted Haggard, whose letter of support, mailed to hundreds of people before he was fired from the church, caused Merrifield to raise questions over church/state separation.
This Friday, a letter signed by Fisk was published in the Colorado Springs Gazette, in which he accuses the lawmaker he lost to of failing the “test of leadership.”
But another letter supporting Merrifield, by Colorado Springs resident Sharon Berthrong, noted that “hypocritical leaders in the charter and voucher movement have employed deception and trickery.”
“We all understand that politics today is a rough business but we should insist that critics be truthful,” wrote Berthrong, a former chairman of the El Paso County Democratic Party.
Yet another Colorado Springs resident, David Knight, termed Merrifield a “breath of fresh air” and a class act.
“The whole voucher flap (excluding successful charter schools and there are many) is all about defunding public education and taking tax money away from poor kids,” Knight wrote. “So thanks, Rep. Merrifield, for working as hard as you have for all the kids in Colorado.”
Cara DeGette is a senior fellow at Colorado Confidential, and a columnist and contributing editor at the Colorado Springs Independent. E-mail her at cdegette@coloradoconfidential.com






View Comments
Comment posted April 6, 2007 @ 5:33 pm
Outrageous letter from Fisk “A lot has been said regarding the inappropriate remarks made by Michael Merrifield – my opponent in 2006 for Colorado House District 18. He wrote that there’s “a special place in hell” for individuals who support public charter schools. Perhaps those of us who support moms and dads making educational decisions for their children should be grateful that at least we got a special place, and did not simply get condemned to the regular fire and brimstone.”
“Merrifield is bought and paid for by the teachers union: more than 70 percent of Merrifield’s $98,375 political war chest amassed in his 2006 election was from union and big labor interests.”
“It’s good Merrifield is no longer chairman of the House Education Committee; he failed the test of leadership. He clearly cannot be objective because he will not even entertain innovative solutions to the myriad challenges facing our state’s education dilemmas. Merrifield is not a “passionate defender of public education” as his liberal Democrat colleagues contend. Rather, he is merely a gatekeeper to ensure that unique and successful educational remedies never see the light of day.”
link
Comment posted April 6, 2007 @ 10:41 pm
Christians aren’t perfect just forgiven.
For being a*holes. Just ask them.
Comment posted April 7, 2007 @ 12:13 am
Merrifield He is arrogant, but follows party direction. For him to gloat about others misfortunes is poor form, but par for his course. He should consider taking only the VC role next season, so he can coach Solano, etc…
Comment posted April 7, 2007 @ 10:10 am
Merrifield The only reason Merrifield apologized was because he was outed, and he still holds that charter schools are bad because they take power and control away from the teacher’s unions. He does not believe in educational choice or freedom. Given Cara DeGette and her dingbat sister are lapdogs of the unions this is nothing but apologist spadework, not objective journalism.
Comment posted April 7, 2007 @ 10:32 am
Cara not objective?! Seriously! LOL… of course Cara isn’t objective. Neither is Mike Rosen or Haryani. The difference is that Rosen and Haryani capitalize on the errors of their political opponents to further explain their philosophical differences. Folks like Cara don’t often think that far ahead and instead insist on trying to defend ridiculous statements like the one MM made. And Morse? He’s no better off. I’m sorry that Mike has cancer and I honestly wish him the very best. But for him or anyone else to use it as a reason to duck absurd statements and political positions that are out of touch is not fair or even proper to expect.
Comment posted April 7, 2007 @ 2:25 pm
Profiteer Lapdogs Rep. Merrifield should not have had to resign over this. Ok, so he made a partisan statement, so what? He is a elected official. That is the problem with elected government. Too many people trying to build bridges to maintain their own political power and not enough people like the late Sen.Wellstone standing up for the truth and common good.
Merrifield did say he opposed all charter schools. He made a blanket statement against those who believe that it is a good idea to systematically turn over the common interests of government to the lapdog profiteers. We already have prisons being run by private profiteers in our criminal “justice” system. How soon will it be before our national parks are turned over to Walmart – And those who do refuse to work overtime without pay are fired “at will” ? Remember due process? Remember checks and balances?
I commend Rep. DeGette who understands that labor unions are needed in this country now more than ever in order
to counter balance the prevasive influence of corporations and powerful government agencies. Employee rights in this nation are far behind other countries despite our high standard of living.
This debate must go on. And if it takes some partisan statements, so be it.
Comment posted April 7, 2007 @ 3:04 pm
I’m sure all you anti-union fools will gladly give back your 40-hour work weeks, two weeks vaca, heath care, and every other perk made standard by our union forebears.
Comment posted April 7, 2007 @ 8:37 pm
These Pols … are hacks Each Pol mentioned in this blog on Morse/Merrifield is a poser, hack, and general turd when it comes to pushing America forward in the education area.
If they had their way they would forbid private colleges, Votechs, charters, etc… Only if you came under a government subdistrict would you be able to educate … and only with union labor and only professing their policies. Read: commie bastard approach.
Kinda like eduction in China and SE Asia. If they really thought it out they’d mandate school uniforms and only allow union textile shops to produce …. Read: dictator control
Here they want to do it b/c of ‘jobs’. Facist bastards, production control scum suckers, just wanting to push their agenda versus Americas future.
Comment posted April 8, 2007 @ 1:05 am
Give it a rest….. Remember what I mentioned about BALANCE? Look at the productive economies in Europe and Canada. Even look at other American States for better examples, like NM.
Comment posted April 8, 2007 @ 9:23 pm
Come ON Cara and the rest of this crew is sure working overtime to cover up for Merrifield’s behavior. How much are the House Dems payin you for this Cara?
Comment posted April 9, 2007 @ 1:16 pm
Let’s discuss the substance, shall we? I’m disappointed at the effort Ms. DeGette makes to deflect the substance of Mr. Merrifield’s comment. I am particularly disappointed that she claims Merrifield’s statement about charter school proponents have “largely misinterpreted” what he said. While it is possible to read the statement to be limited to the two members, as Ms. DeGette claims, the sentence can also be read to mean that ALL charter supporters deserve a “special place.” Indeed, that is the more correct reading, since the sentence does not specifically refer back to the two members.
Also, the idea that Merrifield’s statement only referred to the two members is absurd given the balance of Ms. DeGette’s writing, where she points out that Merrifield has been “An ardent and vocal advocate of public schools” and that he believes all charter schools undo public education and defund schools.
Also, Merrifield’s cancer, while unfortunate, is utterly irrelevant to the issue of his statement regarding charter schools and what it means. While I sincerely hope no one would wish Mr. Merrifield anything but a speedy and complete recovery, his cancer has nothing whatsoever to do with his statement.
Perhaps we could use this incident to pay attention to why Colorado public schools, on average, are consistenly mediocre in national rankings? And perhaps begin a dialogue on how to improve them?
Comment posted April 6, 2007 @ 12:33 pm
Outrageous letter from Fisk “A lot has been said regarding the inappropriate remarks made by Michael Merrifield – my opponent in 2006 for Colorado House District 18. He wrote that there's “a special place in hell” for individuals who support public charter schools. Perhaps those of us who support moms and dads making educational decisions for their children should be grateful that at least we got a special place, and did not simply get condemned to the regular fire and brimstone.”
“Merrifield is bought and paid for by the teachers union: more than 70 percent of Merrifield's $98,375 political war chest amassed in his 2006 election was from union and big labor interests.”
“It's good Merrifield is no longer chairman of the House Education Committee; he failed the test of leadership. He clearly cannot be objective because he will not even entertain innovative solutions to the myriad challenges facing our state's education dilemmas. Merrifield is not a “passionate defender of public education” as his liberal Democrat colleagues contend. Rather, he is merely a gatekeeper to ensure that unique and successful educational remedies never see the light of day.”
link
Comment posted April 6, 2007 @ 5:41 pm
Christians aren't perfect just forgiven.
For being a*holes. Just ask them.
Comment posted April 6, 2007 @ 7:13 pm
Merrifield He is arrogant, but follows party direction. For him to gloat about others misfortunes is poor form, but par for his course. He should consider taking only the VC role next season, so he can coach Solano, etc…
Comment posted April 7, 2007 @ 5:10 am
Merrifield The only reason Merrifield apologized was because he was outed, and he still holds that charter schools are bad because they take power and control away from the teacher's unions. He does not believe in educational choice or freedom. Given Cara DeGette and her dingbat sister are lapdogs of the unions this is nothing but apologist spadework, not objective journalism.
Comment posted April 7, 2007 @ 5:32 am
Cara not objective?! Seriously! LOL… of course Cara isn't objective. Neither is Mike Rosen or Haryani. The difference is that Rosen and Haryani capitalize on the errors of their political opponents to further explain their philosophical differences. Folks like Cara don't often think that far ahead and instead insist on trying to defend ridiculous statements like the one MM made. And Morse? He's no better off. I'm sorry that Mike has cancer and I honestly wish him the very best. But for him or anyone else to use it as a reason to duck absurd statements and political positions that are out of touch is not fair or even proper to expect.
Comment posted April 7, 2007 @ 9:25 am
Profiteer Lapdogs Rep. Merrifield should not have had to resign over this. Ok, so he made a partisan statement, so what? He is a elected official. That is the problem with elected government. Too many people trying to build bridges to maintain their own political power and not enough people like the late Sen.Wellstone standing up for the truth and common good.
Merrifield did say he opposed all charter schools. He made a blanket statement against those who believe that it is a good idea to systematically turn over the common interests of government to the lapdog profiteers. We already have prisons being run by private profiteers in our criminal “justice” system. How soon will it be before our national parks are turned over to Walmart – And those who do refuse to work overtime without pay are fired “at will” ? Remember due process? Remember checks and balances?
I commend Rep. DeGette who understands that labor unions are needed in this country now more than ever in order
to counter balance the prevasive influence of corporations and powerful government agencies. Employee rights in this nation are far behind other countries despite our high standard of living.
This debate must go on. And if it takes some partisan statements, so be it.
Comment posted April 7, 2007 @ 10:04 am
I'm sure all you anti-union fools will gladly give back your 40-hour work weeks, two weeks vaca, heath care, and every other perk made standard by our union forebears.
Comment posted April 7, 2007 @ 3:37 pm
These Pols … are hacks Each Pol mentioned in this blog on Morse/Merrifield is a poser, hack, and general turd when it comes to pushing America forward in the education area.
If they had their way they would forbid private colleges, Votechs, charters, etc… Only if you came under a government subdistrict would you be able to educate … and only with union labor and only professing their policies. Read: commie bastard approach.
Kinda like eduction in China and SE Asia. If they really thought it out they'd mandate school uniforms and only allow union textile shops to produce …. Read: dictator control
Here they want to do it b/c of 'jobs'. Facist bastards, production control scum suckers, just wanting to push their agenda versus Americas future.
Comment posted April 7, 2007 @ 8:05 pm
Give it a rest….. Remember what I mentioned about BALANCE? Look at the productive economies in Europe and Canada. Even look at other American States for better examples, like NM.
Comment posted April 8, 2007 @ 4:23 pm
Come ON Cara and the rest of this crew is sure working overtime to cover up for Merrifield's behavior. How much are the House Dems payin you for this Cara?
Comment posted April 9, 2007 @ 8:16 am
Let's discuss the substance, shall we? I'm disappointed at the effort Ms. DeGette makes to deflect the substance of Mr. Merrifield's comment. I am particularly disappointed that she claims Merrifield's statement about charter school proponents have “largely misinterpreted” what he said. While it is possible to read the statement to be limited to the two members, as Ms. DeGette claims, the sentence can also be read to mean that ALL charter supporters deserve a “special place.” Indeed, that is the more correct reading, since the sentence does not specifically refer back to the two members.
Also, the idea that Merrifield's statement only referred to the two members is absurd given the balance of Ms. DeGette's writing, where she points out that Merrifield has been “An ardent and vocal advocate of public schools” and that he believes all charter schools undo public education and defund schools.
Also, Merrifield's cancer, while unfortunate, is utterly irrelevant to the issue of his statement regarding charter schools and what it means. While I sincerely hope no one would wish Mr. Merrifield anything but a speedy and complete recovery, his cancer has nothing whatsoever to do with his statement.
Perhaps we could use this incident to pay attention to why Colorado public schools, on average, are consistenly mediocre in national rankings? And perhaps begin a dialogue on how to improve them?
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.